Will Barcelona come to regret the loss of their most decorated midfielder?

FC Barcelona’s decision to let Ilkay Gundogan return to Manchester City on a free transfer could soon become one of the club’s most regrettable moves in recent years — which is saying something considering Barca’s damning state of economic affairs.

By allowing the 33-year-old midfield maestro to leave and bypassing any financial compensation, Barcelona has not only lost a veteran presence, but also missed out on an opportunity to profit in a time of financial need.

Gundogan, who joined Barcelona with the intent of bringing stability and leadership to a transitional team, quickly established himself as a key figure. Despite his straightforward style of play, his influence was undeniable—leading the club with 14 assists last season. His ability to provide crucial passes in the final third whilst controlling the tempo of the game made him a savvy asset in Barcelona’s midfield.

Under the guidance of former manager Xavi Hernández, Gundogan became a trusted lieutenant. He brought a wealth of experience from his time at Manchester City, where he was an instrumental figure of a golden era that continues to define dominance under Pep Guardiola. Widely viewed as a modest signing in 2016, Gundo shattered all expectations, securing twelve trophies during his seven-season tenure donning the sky blue. 

His understanding of the game and his ability to deliver in high-pressure situations made him a natural leader on the pitch, but his leadership at Barcelona extended beyond his performances. Gundogan took it upon himself to mentor the squad’s younger players, offering his guidance and support to Barca’s many teenagers and helping them adapt to the demand of top-flight football.

However, Gundogan’s candid nature may have played a role in his premature exit. Rumors began circulating that his post-match criticism of teammate Ronald Araújo, following a red card that played a significant role in Barcelona’s Champions League exit vs. PSG, was not well received by the club’s hierarchy. This, combined with a season that failed to meet lofty expectations, could have accelerated the process of his hasty exit.

The departure of Gundogan now leaves new head coach Hansi Flick with a significant void to fill. Flick, who reportedly viewed Gundogan as integral to his plans for the season, must now find a way to replace his on-field contributions. Players like Fermin Lopez and new addition Dani Olmo will soften the blow of his loss. However it’s Gundogan’s contributions off the pitch that the Barcelona will find difficult to duplicate.

Gundogan’s return to Manchester City will likely see him thrive once more under Guardiola’s watch, and his success will only intensify Barcelona’s reservations about letting him slip away for nothing. The German international has always been a player who rises to the occasion, and his absence will be felt in a Barcelona side that benefited from his poise and expertise.

As Barcelona moves forward, the decision to part with one of the best midfielders of the past decade for free could haunt them, especially if their financial situation sees little improvement. If Gundo proves to be the same dynamic force back in England, the Barcelona board must prepare for a wave of stark backlash regarding their mishandling of his delicate situation.